Choosing who will make decisions for your loved one with dementia is one of the most important and emotionally complex tasks you'll face. A durable power of attorney (POA) gives someone legal authority to manage finances, make healthcare decisions, and handle legal matters when your loved one can no longer do so themselves. Choose the wrong person, and you risk family conflict, financial mismanagement, or decisions that don't align with your loved one's wishes.
The person serving as power of attorney holds tremendous responsibility and power. They'll pay bills, manage investments, communicate with doctors, make care decisions, and potentially determine where your loved one lives. This isn't an honorary title or a way to show you trust someone. It's a serious legal role that requires specific qualities, availability, and willingness to serve.
Here's what to do right now:
- Have an honest conversation with your loved one about their wishes and values while they can still participate
- Identify potential candidates who meet the key criteria
- Assess each person's strengths and limitations realistically
- Schedule a meeting with an elder law attorney to draft the documents
- Have a family meeting to communicate the decision and explain the role
Key Takeaway:
Choosing power of attorney for dementia isn't about picking your favorite person or the oldest child. It's about identifying who has the practical skills, emotional stability, availability, and trustworthiness to make difficult decisions on someone else's behalf for potentially many years, often under stress and family scrutiny.
Understanding Durable Power of Attorney: What It Is and Why It Matters
A power of attorney is a legal document that authorizes someone (the agent or attorney-in-fact) to act on behalf of another person (the principal). There are different types, but for dementia, you need a durable power of attorney, meaning it remains valid even after your loved one loses mental capacity.
Financial power of attorney
Gives the agent authority to manage money, pay bills, access bank accounts, file taxes, manage investments, sell property, and handle all financial matters.
Healthcare power of attorney
Gives the agent authority to make medical decisions, choose doctors and treatments, decide on care settings, and access medical information when your loved one can't make these decisions themselves.
Some states use one document that covers both financial and healthcare decisions. Others require separate documents. An elder law attorney will know what's required in your state.
Why these documents are urgent for dementia:
Dementia progressively impairs judgment and decision-making. Eventually, your loved one won't be able to manage finances, understand medical options, or sign legal documents. If POA documents aren't in place before they lose capacity, the family will need to petition the court for guardianship or conservatorship, which is expensive, time-consuming, invasive, and gives a judge (not family) final say over who serves.
Power of attorney allows your loved one to choose who will help them while they still can. It preserves their autonomy and ensures someone they trust will handle their affairs.
The Qualities You Should Look for in a Power of Attorney
Not everyone is suited to be power of attorney. The role demands specific qualities and capabilities that have nothing to do with how much you love the person or how much they love your loved one.
Essential qualities for a good POA agent:
- Trustworthiness and integrity: This person will have access to all financial accounts and make decisions without daily oversight. They must be honest, ethical, and willing to put your loved one's interests above their own.
- Financial responsibility: The financial POA should have a track record of managing their own money well. If they struggle with debt or poor financial decisions, they're not the right choice.
- Organizational skills: The POA will track bills, manage paperwork, coordinate with multiple providers, and keep detailed records. Disorganized people become overwhelmed quickly.
- Availability and proximity: Ideally, the POA lives nearby and has time to dedicate to this role. Managing from across the country is much harder.
- Emotional stability: This role is stressful. The POA will make difficult decisions under pressure, handle conflict with family members, and witness your loved one's decline.
- Communication skills: The POA should be willing and able to keep family informed, answer questions, and handle disagreements respectfully.
- Willingness to serve: Never appoint someone who is reluctant or feels obligated. This role can last years, and a reluctant POA often becomes resentful.
- Ability to separate emotions from decisions: The POA must make choices based on what's best for your loved one, not what they personally prefer or what feels emotionally easier.
No one will be perfect in every category, but serious deficiencies in trustworthiness, financial responsibility, or availability should disqualify a candidate.
Considering Family Dynamics and Relationships
Family relationships significantly impact who should serve as power of attorney. The person who seems perfect on paper may not work in practice if family dynamics create conflict.
Who gets along with most family members?
If siblings already have strained relationships, appointing one as POA may deepen divisions. Someone who can work collaboratively and handle disagreement maturely is valuable.
Who does your loved one trust most?
While capacity remains, ask your loved one directly who they want in this role. Their preference matters, even if you disagree with their choice.
Is there a history of conflict over money?
If past disputes exist about inheritance, loans, or financial support, appointing someone involved may trigger accusations of bias or misconduct.
Who has time and bandwidth?
An adult child juggling young kids, a demanding career, and their own health issues may love your loved one deeply but lack the capacity to serve effectively.
Are there blended family considerations?
Second marriages, stepchildren, and half-siblings can complicate things. Honest conversations and clear documentation of wishes help.
Does anyone have a conflict of interest?
Someone who stands to inherit significantly or owes your loved one money may face conflicts that compromise their judgment.
You can't make everyone happy, but understanding family dynamics helps you anticipate problems and make choices that minimize conflict.
The Pros and Cons of Common Choices
Families typically consider certain people first for power of attorney. Here's what to think about with each common choice.
Adult children
Pros:
- Deeply invested in parent's wellbeing
- Familiar with family history and values
- Readily available and trusted
Cons:
- May struggle emotionally with parent's decline
- Siblings may resent one child having control
- Geographic distance can be challenging
- Busy lives may limit availability
Spouses
Pros:
- Deeply familiar with person's wishes
- Financially intertwined already
- Usually the first choice of person with dementia
Cons:
- May be elderly with own health issues
- Emotionally overwhelmed by spouse's decline
- Potentially developing cognitive issues
- May face opposition from adult children
Professional fiduciaries or attorneys
Pros:
- Objective and experienced
- No emotional conflicts
- Accountable through professional standards
Cons:
- Expensive
- Less personal connection
- May not understand family values
- Family may feel shut out of decisions
There's no universal right answer. The best choice depends on your specific family, the people available, and your loved one's wishes and needs.
Co-Agents vs. Successor Agents: What's the Difference?
When setting up power of attorney, you can structure it in different ways depending on how much oversight and backup you want.
Co-agents (joint agents)
Two or more people are appointed to serve together. Some documents require co-agents to act jointly (both must agree on every decision), while others allow them to act independently (either can act alone).
Joint co-agents:
Provides strong accountability and checks and balances. However, it's cumbersome for routine tasks and creates gridlock if co-agents disagree.
Independent co-agents:
Each agent can act alone, which is practical for daily tasks. But it offers less protection against misconduct since either agent can act without the other's knowledge.
Successor agents (backup agents)
One person serves as primary agent. If that person can't serve (due to death, illness, refusal, or removal), the successor automatically takes over.
Primary with successor: Keeps decision-making simple with one person in charge while ensuring continuity. The downside is less oversight and all responsibility falls on one person.
Which structure is best for dementia?
For financial POA, many families appoint one primary agent with a successor to keep things simple. For healthcare POA, appointing co-agents who must agree on major medical decisions but can act independently for routine matters can work well. Discuss these options with your elder law attorney.
Questions to Ask Potential Agents Before Deciding
Before finalizing who will serve as power of attorney, have direct conversations with potential candidates. Don't assume someone wants the role or understands what it involves.
Ask these questions:
- "Are you willing to serve as power of attorney? This is a serious responsibility that could last many years."
- "Do you understand you'll need to manage finances, pay bills, coordinate care, and make difficult decisions even when family members disagree?"
- "How much time do you realistically have to dedicate to this? Can you handle phone calls, paperwork, appointments, and potential emergencies?"
- "Are you comfortable keeping detailed records and sharing information with other family members regularly?"
- "How will you handle disagreements with siblings or other family members about care decisions or money?"
- "Are you financially stable enough that you won't be tempted to borrow from or misuse funds?"
- "If the role becomes overwhelming, will you tell us so we can adjust or appoint a successor before things fall apart?"
These conversations should happen before you meet with an attorney, not after documents are signed. If someone hesitates, seems resentful, or doesn't understand what's involved, keep looking.
The Legal Process: Working with an Elder Law Attorney
Once you've identified who should serve as power of attorney, you'll need to work with an elder law attorney to draft the documents legally.
What to bring:
- List of potential agents
- Financial information
- Healthcare wishes and values
- Questions about agent powers
- Information about family dynamics
What the attorney will do:
- Confirm capacity to sign
- Draft state-specific documents
- Explain scope of powers
- Include limitations or instructions
- Ensure proper signing and witnessing
Costs and timing:
Costs: Fees vary but typically range from $300 to $1,000 or more depending on complexity and location. This is money well spent to ensure documents are legally sound and enforceable.
Timing: Do this as soon as possible after diagnosis. Capacity requirements are relatively low, but dementia is progressive. Waiting too long risks losing the ability to sign legal documents.
For more information on essential legal steps, see our guide on legal planning after a dementia diagnosis.
What Happens After Documents Are Signed
Signing the power of attorney is just the beginning. The documents don't take effect until they're needed, which depends on how they're structured.
Immediate vs. springing power of attorney:
Immediate:
The agent's authority begins as soon as the document is signed. This is more common and practical because it allows the agent to help immediately and avoids the need to prove incapacity later.
Springing:
The agent's authority only "springs" into effect when your loved one is declared incapacitated. This creates practical problems. Getting doctors to declare incapacity can be difficult and time-consuming.
Most elder law attorneys recommend immediate power of attorney for dementia because it provides seamless transition as abilities decline.
Steps after signing:
- Provide copies to relevant parties (agent, family, banks, doctors)
- Register with financial institutions
- Set up a system for record-keeping
- Establish communication expectations with family
- Monitor and support the agent
For a comprehensive checklist of POA implementation steps, see our power of attorney dementia checklist.
How to Handle Disagreements About Who Should Serve
Sometimes families can't agree on who should be power of attorney. These disputes can become bitter and divisive if not handled carefully.
Facilitate a family meeting
Bring everyone together (ideally with a neutral facilitator) to discuss concerns and try to reach consensus.
Focus on qualifications, not feelings
Steer the conversation away from "who loves Mom most" to "who has the time, skills, and stability to handle this responsibility."
Consider compromise solutions
Could co-agents work? Could one person handle finances while another handles healthcare?
Let your loved one decide
If your loved one still has capacity, their preference should carry significant weight.
Mediation
If conflict is severe, hire a professional mediator experienced in elder care disputes.
Disagreements are common, but they're manageable if everyone focuses on your loved one's wellbeing rather than personal feelings or control.
Red Flags: When a POA Isn't Acting in Your Loved One's Best Interest
Once someone is serving as power of attorney, family members should stay alert for signs the agent isn't fulfilling their duties appropriately.
Warning signs of problems:
- Refusing to share financial information with family
- Large, unexplained withdrawals or transfers
- Bills going unpaid despite sufficient funds
- Sudden changes to beneficiaries, wills, or trusts
- The agent borrowing money or mixing funds
- Your loved one expressing fear or concern about money
- The agent isolating your loved one from family
- Medical neglect or failure to follow through on care
- Lavish spending on the agent's lifestyle while your loved one's needs are unmet
If you notice these signs, act quickly. Talk to the agent first. If that doesn't resolve concerns, consult an elder law attorney about options for removing the agent or reporting financial exploitation to Adult Protective Services.
Most agents serve faithfully and honestly, but oversight is important. Transparency and regular communication are the best protections against misconduct. To learn more about safeguarding your loved one's finances, see our article on protecting against financial exploitation in dementia.
How CareThru Can Help Power of Attorney Agents Stay Organized
Serving as power of attorney involves managing extensive information: financial accounts, medical records, care expenses, appointments, medications, and communication with family members and providers. Keeping everything organized is essential but overwhelming.
Centralize documents and information: Store documents, track expenses, log decisions, and share information with family members in one secure place.
Document spending for accountability: Financial tracking features help agents document how money is spent. If family members question expenses, the agent can easily show a clear record.
Share access for transparency: Family members can see updates without constant phone calls. This transparency reduces suspicion and builds trust.
Track tasks and deadlines: Set reminders for bill due dates, tax filing, insurance renewals, and medical appointments. Checklists prevent costly oversights.
Support successor agents: If a successor needs to take over suddenly, having everything documented means they can step in without scrambling.
Frequently Asked Questions About Choosing Durable Power of Attorney for Dementia
Should I choose the oldest child as power of attorney?
Not automatically. Birth order doesn't determine who's best suited for the role. Consider practical factors like financial responsibility, organizational skills, availability, and emotional stability. The oldest child might be the right choice, but so might a younger sibling who has more time, lives closer, or has better skills for the role. Choose based on capability, not tradition.
Can I name more than one person as power of attorney?
Yes, you can appoint co-agents who serve together or a primary agent with successor backups. Co-agents provide oversight but can slow decision-making if both must agree on everything. Successors step in only if the primary agent can't serve. Discuss these options with an elder law attorney to structure the arrangement in a way that matches your family's needs.
What if my loved one already appointed someone I think is a bad choice?
If your loved one still has capacity, have a gentle conversation about your concerns and suggest reconsidering. If they've lost capacity and documents are already signed, you can't easily change the appointment. If the agent is acting improperly, you can petition the court to remove them and appoint a guardian, but this is expensive and difficult. Focus on monitoring and supporting the agent unless serious misconduct occurs.
Can a power of attorney agent pay themselves for their time?
It depends on what the POA document says. Some documents explicitly allow reasonable compensation for the agent's time and work. Others are silent, which typically means the agent serves without pay. If the document allows compensation, the amount must be reasonable and documented. Agents should never pay themselves without clear authority in the document and transparent record-keeping.
What's the difference between power of attorney and guardianship?
Power of attorney is created voluntarily by someone while they still have capacity. They choose who will help them. Guardianship is a court process that happens when someone has lost capacity and didn't create POA documents. A judge appoints a guardian who has similar powers but operates under court supervision. Guardianship is much more expensive, restrictive, and invasive than power of attorney.
When does power of attorney end?
Power of attorney ends when the person who created it (the principal) dies. At that point, the executor of the will or successor trustee takes over. POA also ends if it's revoked by the principal while they still have capacity, if the agent resigns and no successor is named, or if a court removes the agent for misconduct.
Can I be power of attorney if I live in a different state?
Yes, but it's more challenging. You'll need to manage finances and care remotely, which requires good systems, trust in local family or caregivers, and possibly more travel. Technology helps, but proximity makes the role much easier. Consider whether a local family member might be a better choice, or whether you can share responsibilities with someone nearby.
What if no family member is suitable to serve as power of attorney?
Consider appointing a professional fiduciary, trust company, or elder law attorney to serve. These professionals are trained, bonded, and experienced in managing finances and care for people who can't do it themselves. They charge fees (typically a percentage of assets or hourly rates), but they provide objectivity and expertise. This can be a better solution than appointing a family member who isn't equipped for the role.
Disclaimer: This article provides general information about choosing durable power of attorney for dementia and is not a substitute for legal advice. Laws regarding power of attorney vary by state. Consult with an elder law attorney in your state to draft documents that comply with local requirements and meet your loved one's specific needs.
Sources
- National Academy of Elder Law Attorneys. (2024). "Power of Attorney." Available at: https://www.naela.org
- American Bar Association. (2024). "Durable Power of Attorney for Finances." Available at: https://www.americanbar.org
- AARP. (2024). "Power of Attorney: What You Need to Know." Available at: https://www.aarp.org/caregiving/financial-legal/
- National Institute on Aging. (2024). "Getting Your Affairs in Order." Available at: https://www.nia.nih.gov/health/getting-your-affairs-order
- Alzheimer's Association. (2024). "Legal and Financial Planning." Available at: https://www.alz.org/help-support/caregiving/financial-legal-planning
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. (2024). "Power of Attorney Guides." Available at: https://www.consumerfinance.gov
- National Guardianship Association. (2024). "Alternatives to Guardianship." Available at: https://www.guardianship.org
- American College of Trust and Estate Counsel. (2024). "Planning for Incapacity." Available at: https://www.actec.org
- Family Caregiver Alliance. (2024). "Legal Planning." Available at: https://www.caregiver.org/resource/legal-planning/
- Elder Law Answers. (2024). "Power of Attorney FAQs." Available at: https://www.elderlawanswers.com