Receiving a dementia diagnosis is life-changing, and it's completely normal to want confirmation or more information before making major care decisions. Whether you're uncertain about the diagnosis itself, uncomfortable with the doctor's approach, or simply want to explore all treatment options, seeking a second opinion is your right as a patient and caregiver.
Here's how to get a second opinion:
- Request copies of all medical records and test results from your current doctor
- Research specialists who focus on dementia and cognitive disorders in your area
- Verify insurance coverage for second opinion consultations
- Schedule an appointment with clear questions about what you want clarified
- Bring all documentation to the new specialist so they can review the full picture
Getting a second opinion doesn't mean you distrust your current doctor or are being difficult. It means you're being thorough about a serious diagnosis that will affect your family for years to come. This article will walk you through when a second opinion makes sense, how to find the right specialist, what to bring, and how to use the information you receive.
Key Takeaway:
Seeking a second opinion on a dementia diagnosis is a normal, responsible step that can confirm the diagnosis, reveal additional treatment options, or uncover conditions that were missed. Request your records, find a qualified specialist, and bring all documentation to ensure the new doctor has complete information for their assessment.
When You Should Consider Getting a Second Opinion
Not every dementia diagnosis requires a second opinion, but certain situations make it especially valuable. Trust your instincts. If something feels off or incomplete about the diagnosis process, it's worth pursuing additional evaluation.
Consider a second opinion if:
- The diagnosis was made quickly without extensive testing (cognitive screening alone isn't always sufficient)
- Your loved one is young (under 65) and received a dementia diagnosis, since early-onset cases require specialized evaluation
- The doctor couldn't specify what type of dementia or seemed uncertain
- Symptoms don't match what you've read about the diagnosed type of dementia
- The doctor dismissed your concerns or didn't answer your questions thoroughly
- No treatable conditions (thyroid problems, B12 deficiency, medication side effects) were ruled out
- You want to explore clinical trials or cutting-edge treatments
- Family members disagree about the diagnosis or next steps
- The doctor suggested aggressive interventions (like stopping driving or moving to memory care) that seem premature given the symptoms
A second opinion is also reasonable simply because dementia diagnosis is complex and you want confirmation before making major life changes. There's no shame in wanting to be absolutely certain.
Understanding Why Second Opinions Matter with Dementia
Dementia isn't a single disease. It's an umbrella term covering Alzheimer's disease, vascular dementia, Lewy body dementia, frontotemporal dementia, and several other conditions. Each type progresses differently, responds to different treatments, and requires different care approaches.
Misdiagnosis happens more often than families realize. One study found that roughly 10% to 30% of people diagnosed with dementia either don't have it or have a different type than initially diagnosed. Some conditions that mimic dementia (like depression, sleep apnea, or normal pressure hydrocephalus) are treatable or even reversible.
Getting the right diagnosis matters because it affects:
- Which medications might help (some dementia drugs work for Alzheimer's but not other types)
- What symptoms to expect and how quickly decline may happen
- What safety concerns to prioritize
- Eligibility for clinical trials
- Legal planning and timing of important decisions
- How you talk with your loved one about what's happening
A second opinion can catch diagnostic errors, provide more detailed staging information, or simply give you confidence that you're on the right path.
Step 1: Request Copies of All Medical Records and Test Results
Before you schedule a second opinion appointment, gather everything from the first evaluation. The new doctor needs to see what testing was done, what the results showed, and how the first doctor reached their conclusion.
Request copies of:
- Office visit notes and the written diagnosis
- Cognitive test results (Mini-Mental State Exam, Montreal Cognitive Assessment, neuropsychological testing)
- Brain imaging reports and actual images (MRI, CT scan, PET scan)
- Lab work results (blood tests, thyroid panel, B12 levels, etc.)
- Any other specialist reports or consultations
- Medication lists and changes made after diagnosis
Call your current doctor's office and ask for a complete copy of your loved one's medical records. Under federal HIPAA laws, you have the right to these records. Some offices charge a small fee for copying, but it's usually under $50.
Many medical systems now offer patient portals where you can download records yourself. If imaging was done (MRI or CT scan), ask for the images on a CD, not just the radiologist's report. The new specialist may want to review the actual scans.
Getting records typically takes a few days to a week. Request them as soon as you decide to seek a second opinion so they're ready when you need them.
Step 2: Decide What Type of Specialist You Need
For a meaningful second opinion, you want a doctor with specific expertise in dementia and cognitive disorders, not just a general practitioner. The right specialist depends on what questions you're trying to answer.
Neurologist
Doctors who specialize in brain and nervous system disorders. Many neurologists have additional training in dementia and movement disorders. Good choice for most second opinions.
Geriatrician
Doctors who specialize in aging and older adults' health. They often have extensive experience with dementia and can evaluate how other health conditions interact with cognitive decline.
Geriatric Psychiatrist
Psychiatrists who specialize in mental health in older adults. Especially valuable if there's question about whether symptoms are dementia, depression, or both.
Neuropsychologist
Psychologists who administer detailed cognitive testing. They don't prescribe medication but provide in-depth assessment of specific cognitive strengths and weaknesses.
Memory Care Specialist or Behavioral Neurologist
Subspecialists who focus exclusively on dementia. Often found at university medical centers or specialized memory clinics. Ideal for complex or unusual cases.
If your loved one is under 65, seek a specialist with experience in early-onset dementia, as the diagnostic process and causes can differ from late-onset cases.
Step 3: Research and Choose a Second Opinion Provider
Finding the right specialist takes some research. You want someone with strong credentials, good reviews, and ideally a different perspective or approach than your first doctor.
Where to look for second opinion specialists:
University medical centers and teaching hospitals:
These facilities often have dementia research programs and access to the latest diagnostic tools and treatments.
Specialized memory clinics:
Many health systems have dedicated memory disorder clinics staffed by multidisciplinary teams.
Alzheimer's Association referrals:
The Alzheimer's Association maintains lists of specialists by region. Call their 24/7 helpline at 800-272-3900.
Your insurance provider's directory:
Check which dementia specialists are in-network to minimize out-of-pocket costs.
Academic research centers:
If you're interested in clinical trials or cutting-edge diagnostics, research universities often have programs specifically for this.
If possible, choose a specialist who practices at a different healthcare system than your first doctor. This brings truly fresh eyes to the case rather than a colleague who might defer to the original diagnosis.
Step 4: Verify Insurance Coverage Before Scheduling
Second opinion consultations can be expensive if you're paying out of pocket. Before you schedule, understand what your insurance will and won't cover.
Call your insurance company and ask:
- Is the specialist in-network or out-of-network?
- Do I need a referral from my primary care doctor for the visit to be covered?
- Does my plan cover second opinion consultations specifically?
- What will my out-of-pocket cost be (copay, coinsurance, deductible)?
- If testing needs to be repeated (like an MRI), will that be covered?
Medicare typically covers second opinions when medically necessary, but you'll still have your standard copays and deductibles. Some Medicare Advantage plans require referrals or have specific networks.
If cost is a barrier, ask the specialist's office about payment plans or sliding scale fees. University medical centers sometimes offer reduced rates for patients enrolled in research studies.
Step 5: Prepare Questions to Ask at the Second Opinion Appointment
Be clear about what you want from this appointment. Are you seeking confirmation of the diagnosis, clarification about the type or stage, opinions about treatment options, or evaluation of whether something was missed?
Important questions to bring to your second opinion appointment:
- Do you agree with the diagnosis of dementia, and if so, what type?
- Was the diagnostic process thorough, or would you recommend additional testing?
- Are there other conditions that could explain the symptoms that weren't fully explored?
- What stage would you say my loved one is in, and how certain are you?
- Do you recommend different medications or treatments than what was prescribed?
- How does your assessment compare to what the first doctor told us?
- Are there clinical trials my loved one might qualify for?
- What would you do if this were your family member?
- Based on what you see, what should our priorities be for the next 6 to 12 months?
Write these questions down and bring them to the appointment. If the second doctor's opinion differs significantly from the first, ask them to explain why in detail.
For more comprehensive guidance, see our article on questions to ask your doctor after a dementia diagnosis.
Step 6: What to Bring to the Second Opinion Appointment
Just like your first dementia appointment, preparation makes a big difference in the quality of evaluation you'll receive. Bring everything the new doctor needs to conduct a thorough review.
Essential items to bring:
- All medical records and test results from the first evaluation
- Your original medication list and any medications prescribed after diagnosis
- The symptom timeline you created for the first appointment (or create one now if you didn't before)
- A list of your questions and concerns
- A second person to help listen and take notes
- Insurance cards and identification
- Any additional observations or changes you've noticed since the first diagnosis
Make sure the new doctor's office has received the records ahead of time if possible. Call a week before the appointment to confirm they have everything.
If your loved one had imaging done (MRI or CT), bring the CD with the actual images, not just the written report. Different radiologists sometimes interpret images differently.
For a complete preparation checklist, see our guide on what to bring to your first dementia appointment.
What Happens During a Second Opinion Appointment
Second opinion appointments for dementia typically last 60 to 90 minutes, similar to the initial diagnostic visit. The doctor will review all previous records, ask questions about symptoms and progression, and conduct their own examination.
The appointment usually includes:
- Interview about symptoms, medical history, and how the person is functioning day-to-day
- Review of all previous testing and imaging
- Physical and neurological examination
- Cognitive testing (may be the same tests or different ones)
- Discussion of the first doctor's diagnosis and treatment plan
- The specialist's assessment and recommendations
The doctor may agree completely with the first diagnosis, partially agree but offer different details about type or stage, recommend additional testing before confirming, or disagree and provide an alternative explanation for the symptoms.
Not all second opinion doctors will give you answers the same day. Some prefer to review everything carefully and call you within a few days with their conclusions. Ask before you leave when and how you'll receive the final assessment.
Step 7: Compare Both Opinions and Decide Next Steps
After the second opinion, you'll need to make sense of what you learned and decide how to move forward. If both doctors agree, you can feel confident about the diagnosis. If they disagree, the path forward is less clear.
If the opinions match:
- You can proceed with treatment and planning with confidence
- Choose which doctor you prefer to work with going forward
- Focus on next steps rather than continued questioning
If the opinions differ slightly:
- Ask each doctor to explain their reasoning
- Consider which evaluation was more thorough
- Look at credentials and experience
- Often the more comprehensive testing is more accurate
If the opinions differ significantly:
- Consider a third opinion from a university medical center
- Ask both doctors what additional testing would clarify
- Evaluate which doctor was more thorough
- Check whether treatable conditions were ruled out
You're not required to "pick a side." You can take the information from both evaluations and seek a third opinion, request additional testing, or ask your primary care doctor to help interpret the conflicting information.
For guidance on what to do once you have clarity, see our comprehensive guide on what to do after a dementia diagnosis.
When Additional Testing Makes Sense After a Second Opinion
Sometimes a second opinion reveals that the initial workup was incomplete. The new specialist might recommend testing that wasn't done the first time.
Additional tests that can clarify diagnosis:
- Advanced brain imaging (volumetric MRI, PET scans that show amyloid plaques or tau protein)
- Comprehensive neuropsychological testing (several hours of detailed cognitive assessment)
- Lumbar puncture (spinal tap) to test cerebrospinal fluid for Alzheimer's biomarkers
- Genetic testing if early-onset dementia or strong family history
- Sleep study if sleep apnea could be contributing to cognitive symptoms
- Additional lab work to rule out rare metabolic or autoimmune conditions
These tests can be expensive and aren't always covered by insurance. Ask whether the results would actually change treatment decisions or care planning. If the answer is no, you might reasonably decline additional testing and focus on managing symptoms based on the information you already have.
How to Handle Disagreements Between Family Members About Second Opinions
Sometimes one family member wants a second opinion while others think it's unnecessary, a waste of money, or disrespectful to the first doctor. These disagreements can create tension during an already stressful time.
Tips for navigating family conflict about second opinions:
- Explain that second opinions are medically appropriate and common for serious diagnoses
- Share specific concerns that are driving your desire for more information
- Offer to cover the cost yourself if finances are the issue
- Suggest that everyone attend the second opinion appointment together
- Frame it as gathering information rather than questioning the first doctor's competence
- Remind family that this decision affects everyone for years and deserves thorough investigation
If one family member is the healthcare power of attorney, they have final decision-making authority. But whenever possible, bringing everyone along for the second opinion helps ensure all voices are heard and the family moves forward unified.
For more guidance on family communication, see our article on how to tell family about a dementia diagnosis.
What to Do If Your Insurance Won't Cover a Second Opinion
If your insurance denies coverage or the specialist you want to see is out-of-network, you still have options.
Strategies for managing second opinion costs:
- Ask the specialist's office about self-pay discounts (often 20% to 40% off)
- Look for teaching hospitals that offer lower-cost evaluations through resident clinics
- Check whether your loved one qualifies for clinical research studies that include free comprehensive evaluations
- Use a medical credit card or payment plan to spread costs over time
- Appeal your insurance denial with support from your primary care doctor explaining medical necessity
The cost of a second opinion typically ranges from $300 to $1,000 depending on location and whether new testing is done. While this isn't small money, it's often worth the expense if it changes the diagnosis or opens up treatment options you didn't know about.
Some families decide to save money by requesting a records review rather than a full appointment. The specialist reviews all medical records and imaging and provides a written opinion without examining the patient in person. This costs less but is also less thorough.
How CareThru Can Help You Organize Multiple Medical Opinions
When you're juggling appointments with multiple specialists, gathering records, tracking different recommendations, and keeping family members updated, organization becomes crucial.
Store all medical records: Keep test results, imaging reports, and doctor visit notes in one place so they're ready when you need them.
Track different recommendations: Note what each doctor said, which medications they prescribed, and how their assessments differed.
Log questions as they arise: Record questions that come up as you compare opinions so you don't forget to ask when you talk to doctors.
Share with family: Family members can see the same information and participate in decision-making even if they couldn't attend appointments.
Reference symptom timelines: Show patterns and progression to new doctors without relying on memory alone.
When you're stressed and dealing with conflicting information, having everything documented and organized reduces anxiety and helps you focus on making the best decision for your loved one.
Frequently Asked Questions About Getting a Second Opinion on Dementia Diagnosis
Will my current doctor be offended if I seek a second opinion?
Good doctors understand that second opinions are a normal part of medical care, especially for serious diagnoses. You don't need to hide it or apologize. Simply say, "I'd like to get a second opinion before we make decisions about next steps. Can you send records to another specialist I'm consulting with?" Most doctors will respect this and cooperate fully with providing records.
How long does it take to get a second opinion appointment?
Wait times vary depending on the specialist's availability and location. Some memory clinics can schedule you within a week or two, while highly sought-after specialists at major medical centers might have waits of one to three months. If your situation feels urgent, explain this when calling and ask if there's a cancellation list you can be added to.
Should I tell the second doctor what the first doctor diagnosed?
Opinions differ on this. Some people prefer to let the second doctor form their own conclusion without bias. Others want the second doctor to specifically review the first diagnosis and explain whether they agree. A good middle ground is to provide all records but ask the doctor to examine your loved one and form an initial impression before discussing what the first doctor concluded.
What if the second opinion is worse than the first?
It's possible the second doctor will deliver more concerning news, such as a more aggressive form of dementia or a more advanced stage. This is hard to hear, but it's better to know the truth so you can plan appropriately. A more accurate diagnosis, even if more serious, allows you to make better decisions about care, treatment, and how to spend the time you have together.
Can I get a second opinion if my loved one already started dementia medications?
Yes, absolutely. Many people seek second opinions after starting treatment, either because medications aren't working as expected or because new symptoms have emerged. The second doctor can review whether the medications are appropriate, whether the dosage should be adjusted, or whether a different treatment approach might work better.
Do I have to switch doctors after getting a second opinion?
No. You can return to your original doctor with the second opinion information and continue care there. Many families use the second opinion to confirm the diagnosis and then stick with the first doctor because of location, insurance, or personal preference. You can also choose to transfer care to the second opinion doctor if you feel more confident in their approach.
How do I know which doctor to believe if they disagree?
Consider which evaluation was more thorough, which doctor specializes more specifically in dementia, whether one doctor ordered testing the other didn't, and which explanation makes more sense given the symptoms you've observed. If still uncertain, seek a third opinion from a university medical center or specialized memory clinic. You can also ask your primary care doctor to review both opinions and offer perspective.
Should I get a second opinion on behavioral symptoms even if I agree with the dementia diagnosis?
Yes, if behavioral symptoms like aggression, paranoia, or hallucinations are severe or not improving with treatment. A geriatric psychiatrist or behavioral neurologist can offer specialized insight into managing behavioral changes that a general neurologist might not have. Second opinions aren't just about diagnosis; they're also valuable for treatment approaches.
Disclaimer: This article provides general information about seeking second medical opinions and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult qualified healthcare providers for guidance specific to your loved one's situation. Laws regarding medical records access may vary by state.
Sources
- Alzheimer's Association. (2024). "Getting a Second Opinion." Available at: https://www.alz.org/help-support/caregiving/daily-care/getting-second-opinion
- National Institute on Aging. (2024). "How Is Alzheimer's Disease Diagnosed?" Available at: https://www.nia.nih.gov/health/how-alzheimers-disease-diagnosed
- Mayo Clinic. (2024). "Dementia: Diagnosis and Treatment." Available at: https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/dementia/diagnosis-treatment/drc-20352019
- Bradford, A., et al. (2009). "Missed and Delayed Diagnosis of Dementia in Primary Care." Alzheimer Disease & Associated Disorders, 23(4), 306-314.
- American Academy of Neurology. (2024). "Practice Parameter: Diagnosis of Dementia (an Evidence-Based Review)." Available at: https://www.aan.com
- U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2024). "Your Rights Under HIPAA." Available at: https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-individuals/guidance-materials-for-consumers/index.html
- Family Caregiver Alliance. (2024). "Dementia Diagnosis and Treatment." Available at: https://www.caregiver.org/resource/dementia-diagnosis-and-treatment/
- Medicare.gov. (2024). "Getting a Second Opinion Before Surgery." Available at: https://www.medicare.gov/what-medicare-covers/getting-a-second-opinion-before-surgery
- Alzheimer's Society (UK). (2024). "Getting a Diagnosis." Available at: https://www.alzheimers.org.uk/about-dementia/symptoms-and-diagnosis/getting-diagnosis
- Knopman, D. S., et al. (2001). "Practice Parameter: Diagnosis of Dementia." Neurology, 56(9), 1143-1153.